GBC AG: The NAGA Group AG | Rating: BUY
Original-Research: The NAGA Group AG - von GBC AG
Einstufung von GBC AG zu The NAGA Group AG
Unternehmen: The NAGA Group AG
ISIN: DE000A161NR7
Anlass der Studie: Research FactSheet
Empfehlung: BUY
Kursziel: 3.60 EUR
Kursziel auf Sicht von: 31.12.2023
Letzte Ratingänderung:
Analyst: Cosmin Filker
First positive effects from initiated restructuring visible; Break-even
expected in the current financial year; Target price: € 3.60; Rating: BUY
Communication with the financial market of NAGA Group AG (NAGA for short)
in the past 2022 financial year was characterised by the postponement of
the 2021 annual report. Part of the delay was related to the clarification
of valuation issues. In the opinion of the auditors, the cryptocurrency
holdings now had to be accounted for at acquisition cost and part of the
customer acquisition costs could no longer be capitalised. Although the
company was in a position to continue on its previous growth path with an
increase in total revenues of 117.1% to € 52.88 million (previous year: €
24.35 million), the changes in the balance sheet led to a significant
decline in EBIT to € -9.55 million (previous year: € 0.94 million).
Due to the delayed publication of the annual report, the 2022 half-year
report was also published late on 30 December 2022. In this report, the
NAGA management paints a picture of a turbulent first half of 2022,
characterised in particular by the collapse of the crypto markets, a
decline in turnover resulting from their withdrawal from the UK and the
overall decline in transaction activity on the capital markets in the wake
of the war in Ukraine. However, due to the still high level of customer
acquisition activities, turnover continued to grow dynamically by 50.1% to
€ 35.02 million (previous year: € 23.22 million), but EBIT was
significantly below the previous year's level at € -18.63 million (previous
year: € -1.95 million). Among other things, the necessary valuation
adjustments of the crypto assets held in the amount of around € -12.00
million were a significant factor in the sharp decline in earnings.
The NAGA Board of Directors has taken the development of the first half of
2022 as an opportunity to initiate a complete change in strategy and a
restructuring since July 2022. On the basis of the product areas that have
now been expanded and introduced to the market (NAGA Trader; NAGAX; NAGA
Pay), the focus has been shifted away from strong customer and revenue
growth towards reaching the break-even point. This is to be exceeded
sustainably from the second quarter of 2023.
Their focus on their trading business and on reducing their operating cost
base and acquisition costs is already bearing fruit, according to the
company. With the improvement in marketing costs, staff reductions and
their cut in R&D expenses, the cost base was reduced to €14 million in the
second quarter of 2022 and further to €12 million in the fourth quarter of
2022. In the first quarter of 2022, this was still at €20 million. This
reduction is partly driven by an improvement in customer acquisition costs.
In Q3, these were € 816, a significant reduction compared to the first two
quarters (Q1: € 1,343; Q2: € 1,609). In Q4 2022, these fell further to €
613. At the same time, an increase in revenue per customer is to be
achieved through geographical diversification.
These measures should only become clearly visible in the current financial
year 2023, but will only have a full impact in 2024. The past financial
year 2022 should still be characterised by a clearly negative result.
The expected high negative operating cash flow should be partly offset by a
positive investment cash flow. This is primarily related to the sale of
money market funds in which NAGA had temporarily parked the liquid funds
raised from the capital increases. A free cash flow of € -3.22 million was
reported at the end of the first half of 2022.
A key aspect of the company's further development is likely to be their
planned strategic transaction with a multinational brokerage company. As
reported by NAGA on 19 January 2023, discussions are currently taking place
with an unnamed brokerage company with the aim of merging the two
companies. The transaction should be completed by the fourth quarter of
2023, subject to a positive due diligence review and other approvals. In
our view, NAGA would be taken over in this case, but their independent
stock exchange listing would be maintained. Obviously, the current
valuation of NAGA is considered low and, on the other hand, the now fully
developed NAGA product range is considered attractive. In the event of an
acquisition, NAGA could benefit from the existing licences of the brokerage
company, which would allow it to enter new markets without having to first
obtain a time-consuming licence.
The current financial year 2023 will be characterised by a focus on
improving the key earnings figures, as described above. In addition, the
company plans to re-enter the UK, where the largest traded volume was in
2021, by Q2 2023. The reactivation of the former customer base (180,000
leads) is to be carried out at lower profit costs, which would have an
immediate effect on earnings. In addition, the company plans to grow more
strongly outside Europe. In this respect, the recently granted licence in
the Seychelles is of great importance. Finally, the introduction of the
NAGA Institutional Desk, planned for the beginning of 2023, is intended to
address volume traders more strongly.
After an expected negative EBIT of € -29.77 million for the past financial
year, with sales revenues of € 52.08 million, in particular due to the
losses in value of cryptocurrencies held, the break-even point should be
reached in the current financial year. With a 30% increase in turnover to €
67.42m, we expect EBIT to improve to € 0.79m. The effects of the UK
re-entry and the further regional expansion should be fully reflected
positively in the coming 2024 financial year. We expect revenue growth of
25% to € 84.27 million in 2024 and consider EBIT of € 10.46 million to be
realistic.
Within the framework of our DCF valuation model, we have determined a
target price of € 3.60 (previously: € 12.75). The significant lowering of
the target price is a consequence of the significantly reduced forecasts
for the concrete estimation period (2022e - 2024e), which provides a lower
basis for the continuity phase of our valuation model. On the other hand,
we take into account the market-related increase in the risk-free interest
rate and thus visibly raise the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) to
10.34% (previously: 9.33%). Based on the current share price of € 1.84, we
assign the rating BUY.
Die vollständige Analyse können Sie hier downloaden: http://www.more-ir.de/d/26351.pdf
Kontakt für Rückfragen
GBC AG
Halderstrasse 27
86150 Augsburg
0821 / 241133 0
research@gbc-ag.de
++++++++++++++++
Offenlegung möglicher Interessenskonflikte nach § 85 WpHG und Art. 20 MAR. Beim oben analysierten Unternehmen ist folgender möglicher Interessenkonflikt gegeben: (5a,11); Einen Katalog möglicher Interessenkonflikte finden Sie unter:
http://www.gbc-ag.de/de/Offenlegung
+++++++++++++++
Date (time) Completion: 03/02/23 (08:24 pm)
Date (time) first transmission: 03/02/23 (11:30 am)
-------------------übermittelt durch die EQS Group AG.-------------------
Für den Inhalt der Mitteilung bzw. Research ist alleine der Herausgeber bzw. Ersteller der Studie verantwortlich. Diese Meldung ist keine Anlageberatung oder Aufforderung zum Abschluss bestimmter Börsengeschäfte.
